Maurice Kirk's body and brain have now been inside government
premises 24 hours a day, 7 days a week since the 22nd of June 2009.
When he left Cardiff prison and arrived at the Caswell Clinic, he was
still on a hunger strike. He realised that there was no point continuing the
hunger strike when he had no access to the courts for at least 28 days. He
broke his fast by eating food brought in by family and friends. This choice was
regarded as paranoid despite the fact that none of the staff eat the food
provided by the institution.
With regard to his physical health, he has observed many changes
during his period of incarceration. He states that during this time period he
has experienced deterioration in eyesight which manifests as loss of focal
clarity, particularly in the morning. He also notes that his hearing has
deteriorated markedly. He observes that his long-term memory appears normal
most of the time but that his short-term memory has weakened. His senses of smell
and taste now vary in intensity. On occasion his heartbeat is slowed and he
feels cold. He has experienced numbness in both arms below the elbows which
disappears when he changes location. He also moves when either one of his feet
becomes cold. He has experienced no dreams since he has entered the clinic and
like one being roused from a state of deep unconsciousness, it takes him over an
hour to feel fully alert each morning. Concurrently his head feels stuffy, as if
his sinuses were blocked. He has also reports that whenever he settles down
somewhere to eat, read and write or sleep, he experiences a sharp pain in the right
ear which lasts for about 30 seconds.
He hopes that these physical symptoms are temporary and that, if he
is ever again permitted to reside on private property his body and brain will
make a full recovery.
The psychiatrists and psychologists at the Caswell Clinic conduct
research on the inmate population in conjunction with the universities of
Cardiff and Swansea. Maurice Kirk has had MRI and CT scans of the brain, but has
neither been permitted to view them nor to receive copies of them. He has not
spent time with a doctor, as would be normal under NHS circumstances, to sit
down and go over them.
It seemed initially that the institution's goal was to diagnose a
dangerous personality disorder. Each psychiatrist has a speciality, and it now
seems that the diagnosis is leading towards a personality disorder caused by
brain damage. Coincidentally Maurice experienced a headache which lasted for
the three days before, during and after his scheduled CT scan.
The Cardiff Court sentenced Maurice to incarceration in the Caswell
Clinic. The documents did not mention compulsory participation in research
projects.
Maurice's experience during these three long months has been one of
delays and petty rules. He has established that the never ending and ever
changing sets of rules at the Caswell Clinic are actually Home Office based. He
has asked for all the rules to be available to all inmates, but the request has
been denied. Instead rules emerge from the ether synchronised to requests from
inmates.
Control of the individual is paramount and is ensured by being under
observation 24 hours a day 7 days a week.
It has been a year of negative press for the South Wales Police. Stories
have been reported about some of the miscarriages of justice which have
occurred over the years. However, the South Wales Police, in their inimitable
way, have sidestepped complaints to the IPCC (Independent Police Complaints
Commission) to which they are bound to respond and have rejected calls from
Cardiff Council for a Public Inquiry into the force's historic miscarriages of
justice.
Chief Constable Barbara Wilding said that the five
miscarriages of justice, which included the Cardiff Newsagent Three and the
three men originally convicted of killing Lynette White, had all been fully
re-investigated.
She said: "What we are referring to here
happened a long, long time ago."
"We have to put this in context, these cases
represent a minuscule percentage of the number of cases that were dealt with by
South Wales Police over that period of time."
She said that the force had completely changed
since that time and there was no suggestion that the same miscarriages of
justice were continuing.
She said: "This is not the same force that it
was in the 1980s."
However that is patently not the case as two events reported by
Wales Online on 29th March 2009 verify.
"South Wales Police has had a difficult week, having to issue two
apologies in the space of 48 hours - the first to a 63-year-old musician who
was mistakenly arrested and strip-searched by armed
police officers and the second to a grieving
widow to whom officers returned the rope her husband had used to kill
himself."
Maurice Kirk would also beg to disagree especially as his arrest and
confinement coincided with his failed attempts to deliver documents to Dolmans
solicitors. The solicitors refused to accept the documents which were actions
against the South Wales Police.
According to the legal directory Chambers and Partners "Dolmans has a
high success rate for the defence of claims for damages and contested trials,
and takes on a steady flow of instructions from its main client base of four
police forces: South Wales Police, Dyfed Powys Police, West Mercia Constabulary
and Gwent Constabulary."
"It has successfully acted for the defendant in a claim for damages
arising out of the claimant's arrest and detention, a case that established an
important precedent in both civil and criminal law in relation to the Mental
Health Act."
The civilian taxpayer initially pays for the police forces and their
CHIS (Covert Human Information Sources) to operate, then they pay for lengthy
court cases and their associated costs, additional costs for years of
accommodation for inmates may follow. The next payment is for solicitors, like
Dolmans, to defend the police for their initial actions plus further court
costs and finally there may be compensation payments calculated in hundreds of
thousands of pounds for those declared innocent.
The South Wales Police cannot afford any additional bad press in
2009. Maurice Kirk's court case has now been moved to 2010. Chief Constable
Barbara Wilding will be retiring at the end of 2009.
Maurice Kirk's court cases and even his Mental Health assessment
have been characterised by a series of delays. By the end of 2009 the delays in
"processing" Maurice will have served their purpose.