Legal Battles : South Wales Police, Caswell Clinic

'HM Partnership' overturn Maurice's £50,000 Judgment, against the HM Prison Governor, Awarded by Trial Judge

Maurice Kirk — Sat, 09 Oct 2010 07:38:00 GMT

1. In a well thought out judgment the HM District judge, Master Phillips, ruled Maurice had lost his compensation and was to pay, instead, HM £2,200 in costs but, at least, 'stayed' proceedings for three months due to the claimant's medical problems. Problems that may continue, sine die, until HM hands over his medical records for surgeon and anaesthetist.

2. The whole case had rested on HM Treasury Solicitor's barrister, today, stating no Particulars of Claim for damages, for his 2008 false imprisonment, were ever received by Cardiff prison from the HM Cardiff County Court manager, Neil Pring. Mr Pring is the very same one currently refusing Maurice the right to process his fourteen ongoing directly related court cases, at the public counter, whilst also deliberately bouncing any 'due process' via court e-mail addresses. Remember, Mr Pring, instigated by HM Attorney-General [see leaked HM internal memos], back in 2002/3, had gathered up, now under the HM Treasury Solicitor's specific orders, all of Maurice's past and present court files for Whitehall scrutiny, despite a success rate of 80% in the fifty odd cases. HM judges wanted to ban him from any civil court, either in England or Wales unless he was represented by a lawyer. A rare move purely to certify him as a Vexatious Litigant. Obtaining the services of a trustworthy lawyer had always been the heart of the problem.

3. Maurice insisted he had paid HM, on 20th April 2009, for service on both Defendants, Ms West, the then Governor of Cardiff prison, just days before their 8th June, MAPPA meeting where her probation/prison representative(s) were then sitting around the table, at their cosy Bridgend police HQ with other MAPPA key players, such as senior police and NHS doctor, Tegwyn Williams and Social Services, Elizabeth Paul, both of special South Wales Police forensic unit, Caswell Psychiatric Prison.

4. The 1st Defendant, in this, the 5th Action against police, was the Chief Constable. She had always admitted court service, on 20th April and had immediately proceeded with voluminous defence, by Dolman's solitors, both in court and directly to Maurice, now detained in HM Cardiff prison. He remained there until his 11th February 2010 acquittal for trading in 'prohibited weapons and ammunition' whilst attempting, Dolmans, solicitors, would say, by 'mutual exchange' of witness statements through their front window. Maurice was still a little upset, apparently, as to the way the Chief Constable had continued to deny, by sworn affidavit, any knowledge of some of his successful Barry magistrates cases and of her officers having broken into his surgery, all matters within some hundred or so incident numbered conflicts with the South Wales police.

5. In June 09 Maurice had applied for a Default Judgment, by letter and had the completed HM form returned from prison to the court. Maurice also raised the whole issue before His Honour Judge Seys Llewelyn QC, in July, following HM Prison having refused his presence at an earlier court and earlier, still, before HHJ N Cooke QC on a routine bail application. Both these judges would have known, of course, about Maurice's MAPPA terrorist level 3 status with HM prison monitoring all of Maurice's visitors, telephone calls and letters to and from the County Court and opening his solicitors.

6. At the 8th June MAPPA meeting HM considered it likely that Maurice would be shot when next attempting to 'exchange' witness statements. It was now his seventeenth year in this long running civil action, repeatedly being refused a Trial by Jury originally promised, originating from when Barry police, on 27th November 1992, had first refused to apprehend or even interview the named likely arsonists who had burnt out his garage at his home in Barry.

7. The garage had hangared his WW2 piper cub (not insured) and also full of his and his father's extensive collection of rare veterinary antique books and equipment (see exhibit, in 4th Action and ITV News video). Maurice was, instead, grilled at the police station by the officer in command, as if he had burnt out his cub to claim on insurance. Police harassment, originating from the 70s, in Somerset, was clearly, again, rearing its ugly head.

8. This time, Maurice was not going to just 'move out of the area', as he had always done before, this time he was going to take a stand and fight them, legally represented, through the civil courts.

9. In the 2009 MAPPA minutes, under the control of Nigel Rees, MAPPA Co-ordinator, reveal Maurice received a majority consent for 'special treatment' with Dr Tegwyn Williams allocated the task, by whatever means, to obtain Barbara Wilding's desire for a 'final solution', Maurice's Broadmoor imprisonment, of 'indeterminate length', IPP, having failed in her opportunity, when deliberately delaying Maurice's arrest for a few weeks, in having him shot.

10. Quotes from 8th Oct 2010 County Court Judgment

P 5 para 23 'The evidence of the 2nd Defendant is that they have no record of having received any correspondence from the court for the period April until October 09 in relation to the proceedings issued by Mr Kirk'.......

P5 para 26 'I accept the evidence of Mr Booty (current HM Governor) that the prison had no record of the prison having received any correspondence from the court for the relevant period. I cannot accept that if the proceedings had been served they would simply have been ignored'.

P 5 para 27 'I do not suggest it is necessary (as Mr Kirk suggests) for there to be an affidavit sworn by the previous governor. He or she will simply repeat the procedures in place in dealing and processing of incoming mail at the prison and that aspect is dealt with in detail in Mr Booty's statement'.

11. In around November 09, when Maurice received the £50,000 Judgment pushed under his prison cell door, immediately arranged, by application to HM Governor's representatives for the distribution of tobacco for all hundred odd inmates on his prison wing.

12. While Maurice cannot commence Court of Appeal proceedings, owing to the Order to 'stay' proceedings, he was just been contacted by the court, mid English Channel, too far out to jump off and swim back to Brittany, where he had gone in search of ten year old police custody videos and tapes. These included the one of police smashing their way into his daughter's car to arrest him, whilst stuck in stationary Cardiff traffic and, later, knocking him about in the cell of the police station.

13. Cardiff court told him that the anxiously awaited judgment, scheduled for Monday, 11th October, as to whether MAPPA meetings summaries will be disclosed or not, was now adjourned to possibly, Friday, 15th October.

Racially Aggravated Threat Trial Starts Today

Maurice Kirk — Wed, 06 Oct 2010 06:32:00 GMT

HM Crown Prosecution are still refusing to hand over my Dr Tegwyn Williams medical records, used on the 2nd December 09, to keep me locked up. Now they affect my trial today, in Barry magistrates, see here. All the HM courts are now blocking my e-mails and I have received a letter from HM Partnership stating I am not allowed to enter any civil or criminal court in South Wales at all, without prior written consent.

Well, past invitations to court have never, actually, been a great thrill, but just how else am I expected to do my target practice now? On a machine gun range?

Leaked Police Report on MAPPA Meetings to Kill Claimant - Contrary to Basic Human Rights!?

Maurice Kirk — Sat, 02 Oct 2010 14:34:00 GMT

Here is just the beginning and here is my shaky speech in the House of Lords meeting, just after my lucky escape, of just why I could not divulge, last year to my family and friends, my defences when charged with a mandatory ten year minimum prison sentence or an Imprisonment for Public Protection [IPP], for life, in a High Security Psychiatric Prison........ Your comments would be greatly appreciated!

In December 09, my London solicitors had written to the police HQ, to MAPPA Co-ordinator, Nigel Rees, who confirmed MAPPA categorisation. The delay in my arrest that followed, around two weeks, was deliberate with the hope I would again make a lawful approach to the Chief Constable, thus allowing police sniper fire to do the rest. There is much video of the incident that sparked all this off. All this police activity, caught on video, but the Crown Court trial judge, Paul somebody, because it was like something out of "The Keystone Cops" blocked it from the jury, following my application for disclosure. Scenes includeded, totally out ofcontrol, 'Trojan' squad of police, armed with their own machine guns, all wearing tin hats, as I attempted mutual exchange of witness statements, in the seventeen year running civil action. This was all being acted out in the inner sanctum of Police HQ, Bridgend. Quite innappropiate for a jury, the judge considered, having already refused any other police disclosure that might further reveal his small minded cabal's ultimate intention.

Maurice Refused Medical Records, Again, for Urgent Operation

Maurice Kirk — Tue, 28 Sep 2010 06:33:00 GMT

His Honour expected me to talk for a week on law, as well, and on legal argument for not striking out the most relevant incidents of misfaesance, malice and deliberate inactivity. These included the Cowbridge Show case, jailed despite Breach of the Peace 'withdrawn', police leaving my vehicles abandoned on the road side, unlocked full of dangerous drugs, stolen cheques by known identified crooks not even interviewed, roundabout case, careless driving for rounding an empty five lane roundabout, two and one half times at 4mph with police caught in court saying ,"we will get the *** driving around in his little white sports car", and the list went on and on.

Case adjourned for 2 weeks for judge written order re MAPPA release of Executive Summaries.... Police fighting tooth and nail, if released here or by Court of Appeal, I cannot publish on website or to be heavily 'redacted', cross out names , organisations etc...I have no worry about the latter.

I had long gone from court, due to too much morphine, possibly, having tried to juggle the amount for pain versus a woolly head! The case continued in my absence for the rest of the day. I was later told by someone in the audience.... Judge not happy about adding 4th Action while police QC used the word 'vilification' more than once, stating my 'game' was always to bring in fresh evidence at the last moment! Rich from him refusing to identify all the police names at each incident or Crime Reference numbers to enquire as to the progress of any of the hundred or so encounters in my eight miserable years.....

I am not fit. So judge is pushing for the case to continue from home....my argument in writing....I cannot get my head round that idea when no court, not even this one, will order police to hand over medical evidence used on 2nd December 09, in Crown Court, in Defendant's 'last ditch' attempt to have me sectioned to Broadmoor, for life.

I was only in court a few minutes today, but did hear judge confirm with police QC, trailing barrister, partner of Dolmans and their hangers on, all acknowledging the police, the Defendant, present in court, did not have the MAPPA 'minutes' of the Barbara Wilding chaired meetings! Why do I bother to attend at all?

"Ladies and Gentlemen of the Jury"

Maurice Kirk — Wed, 24 Mar 2010 23:16:00 GMT

Extracts of the defendant's speech that was never needed, as the jury told us in the Cardiff restaurant afterwards, the end of the first day of evidence was enough for them!

"You have, may I suggest, just heard twelve days of yet another example of our current judiciary system exploiting a personal vendetta, at your expense, this time due to a pending civil action for 'malicious prosecutions and false imprisonments' requiring well over one hundred South Wales Police officers, many retired, being made soon to swear, on oath, as to their reasons behind why, for ten years, I was harrassed whilst working as a veterinary surgeon in the Vale of Glamorgan".

"Losing well over one hundred charges and winning about twelve is only just part of their agenda to have me deprived of income and and the right to practice veterinary surgery".

"Evidence has shown they knew, from the start, that the 'Lewis machine gun' had been decommisioned by Viv Bellamy well over thirty years ago and had been one of several he had placed on his beautiful WW1 replicas I had had the honour to see being built at Lands End aerodrome back in the early seventies".

"In June last year, the twenty odd, many armed, police surrounded our home, in St Donats, on the Sunday, whilst Kirstie and I were drinking tea in the garden. With the police helicopter overhead, they aborted the one million pound "Operation Challice" raid "as you had to be arrested 'away' from the premises" the police officer admitted during cross examination".

"Next day they tried again and succeeded, but refused to admit they found my sixty-four page defendant's statement waiting for them, weighted down by deliberately planted 'ammunition', the very allegation at my arrest, as my phones had been tapped for years as a 'MAPPA level 3 terrorist', level 3 for the top 5% of the most dangerous villians let loose in our society!".

"The chap who sold me the gun was NOT arrested. The purchasing display pilot, like myself, my having been personally invited to fly the DH2 at 2000 Farnbough Air Show by Captain Trubshaw of 002 fame, was also NOT arrested, even though he had 'modified' her and painted her multicoloured."

"So why was his 'black and siver' paint not on the gun in court, why was I and nearly all the others, giving evidence, not allowed to examine her, why did she dissappear to South Wales Police forensic labs in her two thousand miles of perambulations around the country with, purportedly, only one police officer in the car, if they had not considered, for one moment, she was really a prohibited weapon?"

"And that arrogant Dr Tegwyn Williams of Caswell Clinic, South Wales Police Forensic Gulag in Bridgend, telling the judge I had brain damage, by being a long time drinking companion of Oliver Reed and off to Broadmoor I must go! And wicked 'Tom Thumb' Thomalow, HM prosecutor, telling the judge I had a brain tumour as I smouldered in the cells beneath that cess pit, Cardiff Crown Court. What do you make of that if not a conspiracy driven by avarice?"

[And why did my very own Cowbridge Health Centre family doctors repeatedly refuse to have me examined or referred when asked both during and after my acquittal? Why did I have to go to doctors outside Wales?]

"Reliance Custodial Services refusing me my medicine throughout the trial and my fifty-two lever arch files for most of the first week of the trial. Vermin caught in the head lights?

"HM Prison once again deliberately refusing me access to interview witnesses/legal papers during seven months of my incarceration. Relevant to a jury, do you ask? No wonder they want to do away with magistrate and jury systems, our last remnant of the Magna Carta."

It stinks, doesn't it, but the ring leaders will get away with it again, that is our current British custom.

Come to the steps of The Royal Courts of 'Justice', London, to hear more facts and of other cases during Sir Norman's rendition of Gilbert and Sullivan's 'Trial by Jury', our version. Hear more, a lot more, of the wide spread corruption currently in our law courts with the break down of 'the rule of law'. Rumour has it Old Man Scarth has a fine baritone voice, well, in a few notes anyway.

Full transcript on 'downloads' shortly.

M.A.P.P.A. REDACTED MEDICAL RECORDS

Maurice Kirk — Mon, 30 Nov 2009 16:33:00 GMT

BM8473 Kirk
HM Prison
Cardiff
CF24 OVG

29 November 2009

Cardiff Crown Court
The Law Courts
Cathays
Cardiff
CF10 3PG

HM MAPPA REDACTED MEDICAL RECORDS FROM 30+ DOCTORS

Applied for in August 2009 - Received 26 November 2009

Missing contents:

1. GP and Dr Metters records

2. Princess of Wales Hospital records

3. Texas State Psychiatric Hospital Records/Met Police. Dr James (FTAC) records

4. HM Caswell Clinic and HM Cardiff Prison records including from:

5. Dr Bridget Craddock (Police Custody) Seeley Gaynor Jones, L Bragardo and 6 August Tegwyn Williams (HM Prison) just who made the phone call to Dr Williams in my cell?

6. Caswell Clinic (including 16 doctors in 2 hours – 1st September 09 peer review) Psychiatrists: Roger Thomas, Anna Gibbs, Emma Clarke, Janis Hillier, Dr Sylvester, Andrew Chadwick. Psychologists: Professor Roger Wood, Ruth Bagshaw, Darren James, Smolinsk. Psychotherapists: Dr Pat Bray Brooks (see internal emails). Other Doctors: Mary Self, Daffyd Morgan, Alyson Wills, Frances Emeghara, Rajkumai Laksh Manar, Jim Dyson

7. Andy Davies (Clinical Risk Co-Coordinator - see MAPPA/Risk on website.

8. Minutes of meetings written by Elizabeth Paul, Sian Dolling etc.

9. Clinical Notes for August/September 09 whilst in Caswell Clinic

10. Whitchurch Hospital psychiatric records (ordered by Crown Court)

11. Ashworth High Security Hospital Records (ordered by Crown Court)

12. South Wales Police 2 year Covert Surveillance MAPPA meetings minutes (see 1 September meeting). Disclosed content – much more to come.

13. Threat Assessment

Identifies cause due to communication to Tegwyn Williams by Messrs Norman Scarth, Patrick Cullinane, Daffy Morgan and Peter Oakes
Maurice ‘flew’ his plane to Australia without a map
Doctors to consider a potential Section 38
High risk of absconding

14. Alcohol (Brain damage?)
"Mr Kirk reports where he will drink this amount (up to one bottle of red wine daily for a week or two) and then a similar period of time where he will take no alcohol. Mr Kirk reports that he was drinking partners of the actor Oliver Reed, at one stage.”

15. Forensic History.
False, despite repeated complaint to rectify.

16. SPECT Scan. Findings are non-specific.

17. MRI Scan findings are non specific but may represent small ischemic foci. Opinion from these fairy tale 141 pages so far disclosed, under payment to the Data Protection and Freedom of Information, can you also spot four freemasons?

NB Section 38 only applies to a convicted prisoner!

Hang on lads US Calvary to the rescue!
TWO MORE Psychiatrists.

Maurice Kirk

Extract - Psychiatrist's Final Report

Maurice Kirk — Sat, 24 Oct 2009 10:12:00 GMT

AN EXTRACT FROM THE PSYCHIATRISTS REPORT ON MAURICE KIRK.

"Paragraph 36. I have been asked to give my mind to the issue as to whether or not Maurice Kirk is fit to plead and stand trial. Maurice Kirk clearly understands the nature of the charge and the significance of the plea. However, due to Maurice Kirk's mental disorder described above, specifically his brain damage and its relationship to self awareness, judgement, decision making, self regulation of behaviour and control of emotions, combined with difficulty in organising and sequencing information, his inability to filter out relevant information and his problems with attention and concentration, his overwhelming perception of himself as being a victim of persecution by the system, all of which are clearly evident in discussions with him concerning the alleged offence, he appears unable to address a specific legal and technical area of law necessary to appropriately conduct his defence."

"Paragraph 37. Should Maurice Kirk be legally represented in court, I would consider him a fit person to stand trial as a legal representation would be able to focus on the relevant features.

"Paragraph 38. Maurice Kirk's current clinical presentation is clearly causing major problems for the criminal justice system, though is not of a nature and degree to warrant compulsory treatment. He would, however, benefit from continued contact with mental health services to both monitor his condition and attempt to establish a relationship which would allow other treatment avenues to be explored.

"Paragraph 39. I am aware that my opinion will cause significant difficulties for the court.. I am also aware of the difficulties that the court has had gaining further psychiatric evidence which to a degree is due to Maurice Kirk's perceived ability to intimidate and threaten those who become involved in his case. Should Maurice Kirk rerquest in patient hospital treatment. I have concerns that a medium secure unit would not be able to provide the degree of procedural security necessary to maintain the safety of its staff, because of the confidentiality of other patients and the necessary security. Should the court wish a second opinion, they may wish to consider instructing a psychiatrist from a high security hospital to assess Maurice Kirk both as to treatment and the environment in which that treatment should take place. I stress that the requirement for conditions of specific security are purely as a result of Maurice Kirk's communications with the encouragement of others, rather than his clinical presentation.

"Paragraph 40. Maurice Kirk can return to court for any disposal that the court sees fit."

Press / Opinion

Pie2211 — Fri, 16 Oct 2009 19:01:00 GMT

update: broken link now fixed

www.ukcolum.com

www.ukcolumn forums

www.pprune.org

Just Another Frustrating Day In Crown’s Cuckoo Land

Maurice Kirk — Fri, 16 Oct 2009 09:17:00 GMT

‘You can see the rules (policy) if you hand over your cigar lighter', the Ward Manager said, whilst surrounded by her 'heavies' in the doorway of my cell.

Subsequent delivery and a further promise, has, as yet yielded nothing.

So I repeat the academic exercise, a few days later, ensuring this time, there are at least 14 involved. Worrying when the obvious question was put, few it seemed had even seen the Rule Book yet alone Statutory Health and Safety regulations.

Whenever Her Majesty chooses to lock me up, the first job I do is to ‘case the joint' with the view, as so many of my adversaries would have you to believe, to try and escape.

My survey on such places has always been, revealed in confidence towards the end of my internment, but here I am at Her Majesty's pleasure for an indeterminate length of time.

I remember, long ago, a Guernsey born prison officer in the quaint old HM Prison, Dorchester, breaking all the rules and letting me peep at my confidential file.

In it, handwritten, was a note from a certain Taunton Police Office stating ‘Potentially Dangerous and likely to try to escape.

This, the prison officer explained, immediately barred me as an outside gardener at the old people's home, librarian or the plum job, the HM Governor was trying to clear to be his own tea maker and ‘batman.

Perhaps his passion to ‘Break the Bonds of Earth', at every conceivable opportunity, influenced him a little?

And still these ‘shrinks' refuse to read the evidence brought in by my good wife, for fear it may endanger their ‘interim diagnosis' of paranoid delusional disorder.

A ‘Hunger Strike’ or Just ‘Not Eating?’

Maurice Kirk — Fri, 16 Oct 2009 09:14:00 GMT

On the 8 October I may have just lost my appetite but, since then, apart from the occasional apple or grape, I have ‘refused food'.

I do not expect much to change until I am given my medical records from both State Psychiatric Hospital, Austin, Texas and the South Wales Forensic Service.

Informed interrogation of both patients and staff of the Caswell Clinic, Bridgend, leaves me in no doubt that I was taken from HM Prison, Cardiff on the pretext my so called ‘hunger strike' indicated a ‘psychiatric disorder' in order to prevent me ‘preserving evidence'.