I come back from France to arrest Barbara and Adrian, the latter could not be found in Dolmans, Cardiff nor could the former, on my visit to Barry Police Station being told Inspector Rice will not see me for a witness statement! Sgt Rice, as he was in '97, burst into Barry Magistrates with a van load of excited coppers upon my insistance. Sirens could be heard all the way from Gladstone Rd Police Station to the court house, as I shook Crown Prososecutor, Stoffa, by the scruff of the neck, as my Jack Russell would kill a rat.
|
Location |
Names of Officers/
Individuals
Alleged by
Claimant
M Kirk BVSc |
Names of Officers/
Individuals
Alleged by
Defendant
South Wales Police |
Charges
brought
or reported
|
Charges or reports
Withdrawn or
Quashed
by whom? |
Conviction and which
charges |
Appeal
Which
charges |
Outcome of
Appeal
Judges? |
Vehicle, its
Nationality and name of
registered
keeper
|
|
|
|
|
A48-Cowbridge. Stopped defective light |
PS Huw Phillips
Helen Phillips CPS
Marianne Fanshawe
Ms J Caress
Clerk of Court |
PS Huw Phillips
Clare Willis
Insp. Sidney Griffiths
Linda Young
John Kirkpatrick
|
1.No insurance
2.No MOT
3. No Tax
4.Rectification ticket |
2. &3. Withdrawn by CPS |
1.& 2. Upheld in claimant's absence
24/5/93 |
All |
All Quashed in claimant's absence
03/6/93
|
Ford Escort
Guernsey
Marianne Fanshawe |
|
Veterinary surgery, Barry burgled again and thief caught by Claimant
(sample from 74 other incidents not in this schedule as blocked by successive members of HM Partnership) |
Inspector Sydney Griffiths
Inspector Manners
Inspector Trigg
Superintendant Jones
Police surveillance team parked right outside surgery |
Police refuse any disclosure at all |
|
|
|
|
|
Any selection from 15 vehicles would have been parked outside the surgery, at any one time, rotated daily, just to confuse Defendant but allow the Claimant to practice veterinary surgery |
|
Defective tyre outside Claimant's surgery at Tynewydd Road
Barry |
PS Jane Lott
Scott Parry
Inspector RI Manners
M Holmes
S Kirke
Inspector Price
Court Usher
|
PS Jane Lott
Insp. Coliandris |
1.Defective tyre
2.No Tax |
No. 2. by CPS |
Defective tyre |
1. |
Quashed
(PC altered traffic ticket between issue and Appeal)
17/12/93
Judge Birt |
Ford Escort
Guernsey
Marianne Fanshawe |
|
Arrested outside Claimant's surgery, Grand Avenue, Ely re BMW motor bike |
PC Phillip Thomas
BJ Price PC3150
Prison governor
Ian Williams
Dr Watson
Thomas PC3052
Inspector Trigg
M Powell |
DC Phillip Thomas
PC Beer
DC David Griffiths
DS Robert Powell
PC Paines
PS Huckfield
PS Denis Crutcher
PC Donovan
PC Brown |
1.Theft of bike 2.Garrotte type
Instrument
3.Assault
4.No insurance
4. No MOT
5.No tax
JAILED
25/5/93 |
All charges withdrawn by CPS |
|
|
|
BMW 1000cc
Motorcycle
Guernsey
Marianne Fanshawe |
|
Bridgend Police - stopped |
Duty Sargeant
Mrs Kirstie Kirk
passenger
|
PC Simon Rogers
Insp. Andrew Rice |
1.No Driving licence
2.No Insurance
3. No MOT |
All withdrawn by CPS or police? |
|
|
|
Escort Cabriolet
UK
Ms K Webb |
|
Stopped at St Nicholas, Vale of Glam - no VEL |
Mrs Kirstie Kirk
passenger |
PC Ivor Hillman
PC Billington
22/9/93 |
1.Driving whilst disqualified
2.No insurance
+?
04/10/93 |
All charges
Withdrawn by CPS |
|
|
|
Spitfire
UK
Amy Johnson |
|
Arrested in St Athan on suspicion of driving whilst disqualified. |
Stephen Booker
|
Stephen Booker
Ps Roy Goodman
PC McDonagh (deceased)
|
1.Driving whilst disqualified
2. No insurance
3. No tax
4.No MOT
JAILED |
All charges
Withdrawn by CPS |
|
|
|
BMW 1000cc Motorcycle
Guernsey
Joseph F Bloggins
|
|
After visiting Barry Police Station - stopped at roundabout outside. |
PC Kerslake
PC Simon Rodgers
PC Bassett
Jackie Seel
Jane Walker
Linda Holland
Judge Evans QC
|
Nigel Reid
DC Michael Hill
PC Julian Kerslake
PS Gareth Owen
PC Simon Rodgers
PS Alan Cowley |
1.Driving whilst disqualified
2.No insurance
3. No tax
4.No MOT
5. Fail to stop
6.Careless driving at 4 mph JAILED
|
1,3. and 4 withdrawn by police or CPS |
1)Fail to stop
2)without due care |
All |
All Upheld
Judge Evans |
Honda Act van
Guernsey
Maurice Kirk
|
|
Claimant's BMW motorbike stolen from rear of surgery, Tynewydd Road
|
Under cover surveillance police |
PC Christopher Driscoll
Insp. Sidney Griffiths |
Surveillance police removed number plates to obstruct stolen bike identification. |
N/A |
|
|
|
BMW 1000cc Motorcycle
Guernsey
Joseph F Bloggins |
|
Claimant alleges stopped on Manor Way, Cardiff , |
Duty sergeant Mrs Kirstie Kirk
passenger |
None as no record of incident |
1.Fail to produce
2.No insurance |
Withdrawn by CPS |
|
|
|
Ford Cabriolet
UK
Ms Kirstie Webb |
|
Pontypridd Road, Barry |
PC Kerslake
Insp. David Smith
Diane Graham
|
PC Kerslake
Insp. David Smith
Insp. Davies
PC Crabtree
09/08/94 |
1.Driving whilst disqualified
2. No insurance
3.No MOT
JAILED |
Withdrawn by CPS |
|
|
|
Spitfire
UK
Amy Johnson
|
|
Outside Barry Police Station - after release |
PC Kerslake
Insp. Howard Davies
2pm Duty Sergeant
Diane Graham |
Insp. Howard Davies
DC Venners
Insp. Smith
DI Kendall
PC Crabtree |
Criminal damage
JAILED
09/08/94 |
Withdrawn by police
|
|
|
|
Coroner's car
UK
|
|
Near Barry Police Station |
Linda Holland
Insp. Smith
Diane Graham |
Insp. Smith
DC Dinelle Francis
PS Roy Goodman
API Merit
Superintendant Francis |
1.Driving whilst disqualified
2. No
Insurance
+?
JAILED
10/08/94 |
All withdrawn
By CPS |
|
|
|
Spitfire
UK
Amy Johnson |
|
52/53Tynewydd Road, Barry - assault on Claimant by Paul Stringer |
PC John Johnson
Linda Holland
Diane Graham
21/07/95 |
PC Jonathan Johnson |
Stringer assault |
|
|
|
|
N/A |
|
51/53Tynewydd Road, Barry - further assault by Paul Stringer |
Mr Paul Stringer
Linda Holland
Diane Graham
Under cover
surveillance police
|
PC Martyn James |
Stringer
Actual Bodily Harm |
Charge against Stringer withdrawn due to" lack of evidence" |
|
|
|
N/A |
|
Claimant's Surgery - attempt to break in by Paul Stringer |
Mr Paul Stringer
Linda Holland
Insp. Sydney Griffiths
surveillance
police |
None as no record of incident |
N/A |
|
|
|
|
N/A |
|
Not stated - further assault by Paul Stringer |
Mr Paul Stringer
Linda Holland surveillance
police |
None as no record of incident |
N/A |
|
|
|
|
N/A |
|
52 Tynewwydd Road, Barry - criminal damage to property by Paul Stringer |
Mr Paul Stringer
Linda Holland
Diane Graham surveillance police |
None as no record of incident |
N/A |
|
|
|
|
N/A |
|
Claimant's Property,
Cardiff surgery,
Cowbridge Road |
Inspector Jenner
Ms Alison Jenner
Anthony Gaphael
Mr Peach
Mr G Thomas
Mr Harrison
Mr D Jones |
None as no record of incident |
1.Eviction of Tenants Act
2,Criminal damage |
All Charges withdrawn by CPS |
|
|
|
Police vehicles carrying, at least, a crow bar and sledgehammer
used to break into surgery |
|
Action 2 - CF101741
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Flight from Cardiff to Southern Ireland - Information laid before Barry Magistrates |
DC Murphy
DC Gibbs
PC McBride
Sue Jenkins
London CPS
RRB Munday
Christopher Paul
Ebbs
under cover surveillance police |
DC Murphy
DC Gibbs |
Breach of Terrorism Act
Feb 96
First interviewed
April 96? |
|
Stopped part heard
and
quashed |
|
|
1954 Piper Colt
Aircraft
UK
Maurice Kirk |
|
|
St Athan B4265 |
PCA Stephens
PC Simon Rogers
Diane Graham |
PC Andrew Stephen
PC Simon Rogers |
1.Careless driving
2.cross white line at 4mph
3. No insurance |
3. withdrawn by CPS |
1. Careless Driving.
2. Cross single white line at 4mph.
Guilty Plea rendered MK "unfit to practice veterinary medicine"
6th Jan 05 RCVS Judgment |
No. 1. only |
Quashed
Judge Gaskell |
Austin Allegro veterinary ambulance
UK
Amelia Earhart |
|
Barry - Link Road |
PC Roche
Diane Graham |
PC Andrew Roche |
1. defective bumper
2. cracked windscreen
3. defective light
4. No insurance
5. Fail to produce
6. no seat belt |
Utter
Confusion
No. 6 removed by CPS |
All remaining Upheld |
All charges
|
All quashed
PC altered traffic ticket
Presiding Judge? |
Ford Orion
UK
Buzz Aldrin
|
|
St Nicholas |
PS Rice and 2 full ‘paddy' wagons
PC Ridley
Ms J Caress
Dawn Hawkins
R Hirst
Mr Stoffa, CPS, |
None |
1.Speeding
2.No insurance |
|
Stopped Quashed
CPS file seized and prosecutor arrested |
|
|
Austin Allegro veterinary ambulance
UK
Amelia Earhart |
|
Southey Street, Barry |
PC G Holmes
Diane Graham |
DC McGregor
PS Greaves
PC Gareth Holmes |
Fail roadside breath test?
Fail produce documents
|
All Withdrawn by CPS |
|
|
|
Citroen, Volvo or one of six other vehicles
Leigh Mallory, Jean Batten or Joseph F Bloggins |
|
Flying - St Donats
Vale of Glamorgan |
Andrew Aishe
Air Traffic Traffic
Control Cardiff and Staverton airports
Williamson CAA |
PC Walters (Gwent Police)
PC Hayes
PC Philip Bracegirdle (Gwent Police) |
Reported to CAA
Flying without valid licence |
Draft charges Withdrawn |
|
|
|
1943 Piper Cub G-KIRK
Aircraft
UK
Maurice Kirk |
|
Pontypridd Road, Barry |
PC Abi Brown
SPC Lewis
Insp. Jonathan Lott
Dawn Hawkins
Diane Graham
|
PC Abi Brown
SPC Lewis
Insp. Jonathan Lott
Diane Griffiths |
1.Traffic light
2.No insurance
3. No MOT
4. Fail to produce documents
5. Fail roadside
Breath test
JAILED |
Zero reading at police station
No. 5. withdrawn |
1.Traffic light
2.No insurance
3. No MOT
4. Fail to produce docs
|
All charges |
All Quashed
Judge Jacobs |
Ford Estate
UK
D Williams MRCVS |
|
St Athan B4265/Llantwit major |
PC Kihlberg
PC Humphreys
Ms J Caress
Insp. Bohun
Dawn Hawkins
Judge Jacobs
Judge Seys Llewellyn
CPS |
PC Humpreys
PS Faulkner
PC Anthony Kihlberg
PC Gareth Holmes
Insp. Bohun
PC Uprichard
PC Keith Crabtree
Vivienne Teresa Davies |
1.Fail to supply Roadside breath test
2. No insurance
JAILED |
Claimant offered Obstruction charge by CPS, mid hearing, in place of ‘refuse breath test' |
Fail to supply Roadside breath test |
Fail to supply
Road side ‘chat' or breath test |
Upheld in claimant's absence.
Medical note ridiculed
Presiding judge? |
BMW 7 series
UK
Miss Jean Batten |
|
Link Road Breath Test - A4050 south of Junction 33 of M4 |
PC Guest
PC Wellbeloved |
PC Guest
PC Wellbeloved |
|
|
|
|
|
BMW 7 series
UK
Miss
Jean Batten |
|
Newport Road / Albany Road, Cardiff |
PC Osbourne
PS Geoffrey Roberts
PS Pickett
PS Mahony
Dr Lush
PC Price
PC Coles
Dawn Hawkins
Diane Graham
Miss B Kirk |
PC Osbourne
PS Geoffrey Roberts
PS Pickett
PS Mahony
Dr Lush
PC Price
PC Coles |
1.No seatbelt 2.Using mobile
3.Refuse roadside breath test
4.No insurance
5. No MOT
Beaten up JAILED and beaten up again |
1, 2 & 5
Withdrawn by CPS
4. Quashed |
Refuse road side breath test |
Refuse road side breath test |
Upheld
Presiding judge? |
Peugeot
UK
Miss B Kirk
|
|
A473 - towards Bridgend |
PC Rewbridge
Court manager
Chief Sup Jones
Unnamed police inspector, in well of court, caught signalling to police in witness box
Diane Graham
CPS
Judge N Cooke
All 12 members of the jury |
Insp. Steven Evans
PC Linda Rewbridge
PC Smith
PC Bowers |
Dangerous driving
Or
Driving without due
care
JAILED |
|
Stopped by judge to Order Not Guilty Verdict
Claimant instead is
Jailed
while RCVS
deny all knowledge
of incident |
|
|
Ford Escort Estate
UK
D Williams MRCVS
|
|
Church Street, Llantwit Major |
PC Kihlberg
PC Gareth Holmes
Diane Graham
|
PC Robert Morgan
PC Anthony Kihlberg
PC Gareth Holmes
PC David Barrett
Insp. Hubbard
PS McCarthy
PC Gary Hayes
PS Nigel Streeter |
Public Order
JAILED |
Withdrawn by CPS |
|
|
|
BMW 7 series
UK
Miss Jean Batten |
|
Outside Cardiff County Court |
PC Gunstone
Court security
Court manager
Diane Graham
|
PS Daryl Fahey
PC Gunstone
PC Stone |
Obstruction
JAILED |
Withdrawn by police |
|
|
|
VW Campaign Wagon
UK
Mrs VA Kirk |
|
Claimant Surgery 175 Cowbridge Rd Cardiff |
PC2673
PC301
Diane Graham |
PC 301 Zachary Mader |
1.No insurance
2. Fail to produce |
Withdrawn by CPS |
|
|
|
VW Campaign Wagon UK
Mrs VA Kirk |
|
Vale of Glamorgan Show - Fonmon |
PC Walters
Dennis Davies
Andrew Morris
S Kearsly-Evans
Insp. Howard Davies
Jackie Seel
Roger T Martin
Andrew Jones
Ieuan Rees
Diane Graham |
PC Walters
Insp. Christopher Patterson
PC Pearce
PS Rice
Insp. Howard Davies
Byron Williams
Simon Turner
Elaine Carr
Maurice Dwek |
JAILED
The ‘Complaint' before court is still undisclosed by Defendant having hidden it now from the Claimant, 11 judges and 18 magistrates. |
Withdrawn by
CPS |
|
|
|
Austin van
UK
Miss Amelia Earhart |
|
Cash Generators, Barry - stolen cheques |
Claimant alleges inaction by the Defendant and therefore does not name any officers as being involved |
PS Hubert James
PC Heidi Dilworth
PS Tumelty
PC Walker
PC Wintle
Mr Shaft
PC Bradbury |
|
|
|
|
|
N/A |
|
A473 Cowbridge Road, towards Bridgend |
Dawn Hawkins
Diane Graham |
PC Clive Barber
DS Davies |
No insurance |
Withdrawn by CPS in
court |
|
|
|
Ford Granada?
UK
Wilfred Barker |
|
Hayes Monument - Cardiff City Centre |
Mark Cocksey
PC Robert Osbourne
Dawn Hawkins
Diane Graham
|
PC Mark Cocksey
PC Robert Osbourne
PC Andy James
PS Linda Canterbury
PS Geoffrey Roberts
PC William Roberts
PC Adrian Williams
PC Tracey Selleck |
1.Driving whilst disqualified
2. No Insurance
+?
JAILED |
|
All dismissed |
|
|
VW Campaign Waggon
UK
Mrs VA Kirk |
|
Westgate, Cowbridge,
Vale of Glamorgan
Outside police station |
PC Bickerstaff
PC Holehouse
Court clerks
Dr M Coleman
Dr Baig
PS Robert Davidson
PS James Hall
Dawn Hawkins
Diane Graham
Volvo driver known to police
Passing van driver
|
PC Bickerstaff
PC Holehouse
PS Robert Davidson
PS Michael George
PS James Hall
PC Thomas Warren
PC David Giboney
PC Claire Baxter-Jones
PC Richard Collins
PC Damian Seaton
Dr A Baig
Dr Martin Coleman |
1.Driving whilst disqualified 2.PublicOrder
(frightened two large policemen)
3.No insurance
JAILED |
|
Number 2. |
No. 2 |
Stop by judge part heard and
quashed
Judge Pearce? |
VW Campaign Waggon
UK
Mrs Violet Alicia Kirk, Claimant's long suffering mother |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|